British GP: Smedley takes responsibility
By Andrew Hooper
July 6 2014
British GP: Smedley takes responsibility
Posted by: Williams F1 (IP Logged)
Date: 06/07/2014 06:50
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.
Re: British GP: Smedley takes responsibility
Posted by: roadie (IP Logged)
Date: 06/07/2014 09:48
Why is Smedley talking about pole when all was needed was to get through Q1?
Surely if you don't know what is going to happen it is best to get a banker lap in early to leave time to react if conditions do change later in the session!
Were the team overconfident and just trying to be cute?
Surely if you don't know what is going to happen it is best to get a banker lap in early to leave time to react if conditions do change later in the session!
Were the team overconfident and just trying to be cute?
Re: British GP: Smedley takes responsibility
Posted by: Anderis (IP Logged)
Date: 06/07/2014 10:11
I think that if you have a good car, if conditions are changeable, you should watch what teams around are doing and do the same.
If you have a worse car, then you can take a risk and try something different just in case it could be right 1 out of 3 or 4 times, since you don't risk to lose anything. But as far as I could see, Williams for some reason tried to start their timed laps quite a bit later than all of the grid. What's the point? With car like FW36, you don't need to have an ideal lap in Q1 to make it into Q2. In changeable conditions, you don't need to post the fastest time possible, you only need to do better than 1/3 of the grid in Q1. So you should try to copy what other teams are doing and you're pretty much safe.
I can't think of any other team who came even close to Williams in getting it wrong in changeable conditions in recent years.
If you have a worse car, then you can take a risk and try something different just in case it could be right 1 out of 3 or 4 times, since you don't risk to lose anything. But as far as I could see, Williams for some reason tried to start their timed laps quite a bit later than all of the grid. What's the point? With car like FW36, you don't need to have an ideal lap in Q1 to make it into Q2. In changeable conditions, you don't need to post the fastest time possible, you only need to do better than 1/3 of the grid in Q1. So you should try to copy what other teams are doing and you're pretty much safe.
I can't think of any other team who came even close to Williams in getting it wrong in changeable conditions in recent years.
Re: British GP: Smedley takes responsibility
Posted by: Gunk (IP Logged)
Date: 06/07/2014 11:59
Exactly, Anderis.
Are Smedley and Pat on the same page??
When criticised for not being aggressive in Austria, Pat said the team was being 'risk averse'. Now Smedley wants to risk it all even in Q1. Something here doesn't chime.
Williams has improved in almost every area except trackside - strategy is still its weakest link. Is the honeymoon period with Smedley over?
Are Smedley and Pat on the same page??
When criticised for not being aggressive in Austria, Pat said the team was being 'risk averse'. Now Smedley wants to risk it all even in Q1. Something here doesn't chime.
Williams has improved in almost every area except trackside - strategy is still its weakest link. Is the honeymoon period with Smedley over?
Re: British GP: Smedley takes responsibility
Posted by: Bond (IP Logged)
Date: 07/07/2014 07:26
Everybody made a big deal of the screw up on Sat. But it was a window of about 1.5 mins that cost the team a shot @ Q2. Yes weather doe move that fast in Summer over a 3.6 miles track. That said, P2 on Sunday made it all worth it.
Smedley is a standup guy. He said it was his fault & the buck stops there. Well the credit should also go there also for the P2 on Sunday!
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2014:07:07:07:27:18 by Bond.
Smedley is a standup guy. He said it was his fault & the buck stops there. Well the credit should also go there also for the P2 on Sunday!
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2014:07:07:07:27:18 by Bond.
Re: British GP: Smedley takes responsibility
Posted by: Lurcher (IP Logged)
Date: 07/07/2014 08:41
Smedley is a huge asset to us. Would you rather an honest guy who admits when he gets it wrong or someone who will blame anything and anyone else for their mistakes? For me, that's the difference between an engineer and a politician.
Re: British GP: Smedley takes responsibility
Posted by: andy si (IP Logged)
Date: 07/07/2014 15:23
Being critical of yourself is a good thing.
Learning from your mistakes is an even greater one.
Bravo Williams and the team!
PS: despite the mess that was Friday and Saturday for the team, our drivers obviously had a competitive setup on their cars!
Learning from your mistakes is an even greater one.
Bravo Williams and the team!
PS: despite the mess that was Friday and Saturday for the team, our drivers obviously had a competitive setup on their cars!
Re: British GP: Smedley takes responsibility
Posted by: Bond (IP Logged)
Date: 07/07/2014 16:05
If you guys are interested, there are ton of Smedley videos on youtube that is very revealing of his makeup.
Top notch character & team player. No wonder Massa loved him as his engineer. & why Williams is fortunate to have him head their on-track performance revival.
Top notch character & team player. No wonder Massa loved him as his engineer. & why Williams is fortunate to have him head their on-track performance revival.
Re: British GP: Smedley takes responsibility
Posted by: Mansell`s flying wheelnut (IP Logged)
Date: 08/07/2014 18:27
Rob and Susie are currently doing a Q&A on twitter and I asked this
RS what actually broke on Felipes car that couldn't be fixed and if you knew the red flag would be 1 hour could it be repaired ? #datadriven
Rob's reply
WILLIAMS RACING ‏@WilliamsRacing · 4m
@fred280 RS: The differential and the driveshaft were broken and could not be repaired in the time we had #datadriven
Like Lurcher said Rob is a huge Assett for us and a really likable bloke to boot.
----------------------------------------
There are stories that Williams will go the way of Tyrrell. Well, over my dead body. No way. That's not going to happen. My dream is to make this a world championship-winning team again. Claire Williams
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2014:07:08:18:29:35 by Mansell`s flying wheelnut.
RS what actually broke on Felipes car that couldn't be fixed and if you knew the red flag would be 1 hour could it be repaired ? #datadriven
Rob's reply
WILLIAMS RACING ‏@WilliamsRacing · 4m
@fred280 RS: The differential and the driveshaft were broken and could not be repaired in the time we had #datadriven
Like Lurcher said Rob is a huge Assett for us and a really likable bloke to boot.
----------------------------------------
There are stories that Williams will go the way of Tyrrell. Well, over my dead body. No way. That's not going to happen. My dream is to make this a world championship-winning team again. Claire Williams
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2014:07:08:18:29:35 by Mansell`s flying wheelnut.
Re: British GP: Smedley takes responsibility
Posted by: pitlane_bimbo (IP Logged)
Date: 09/07/2014 17:01
Quote:Bond
Smedley is a standup guy. He said it was his fault & the buck stops there. Well the credit should also go there also for the P2 on Sunday!
With respect, Bond, I think the credit for Sunday is entirely down to Bottas.
You know, putting two wheels on the wrong way round, and putting two cars at entirely the wrong end of the grid - thereby losing one of then - isn't something even amateurish Williams do that often.
Re: British GP: Smedley takes responsibility
Posted by: Bond (IP Logged)
Date: 09/07/2014 17:27
Quote:pitlane_bimboQuote:Bond
Smedley is a standup guy. He said it was his fault & the buck stops there. Well the credit should also go there also for the P2 on Sunday!
With respect, Bond, I think the credit for Sunday is entirely down to Bottas.
You know, putting two wheels on the wrong way round, and putting two cars at entirely the wrong end of the grid - thereby losing one of then - isn't something even amateurish Williams do that often.
With all due respect: F1 is rarely ever the drivers only making the difference.
There is usually 500+ moving parts at Williams to all blend & fit together to get to that P2 on Sundays.
& these foibles you mention have been a Williams trait for the last 10 years.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2014:07:09:17:28:13 by Bond.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.



